The Attribute Index: Adverse Impact Studies in Pre-hire Roles

by | Attribute Index, DISC University

When considering the use of the Attribute Index for pre-hire assessments, it’s crucial to understand and mitigate the risk of adverse impact on protected groups. Adverse impact occurs when a seemingly neutral hiring practice disproportionately excludes members of a protected group (such as based on race, sex, age, etc.) under civil rights laws in the United States.

To ensure that pre-hire assessments like the Attribute Index do not lead to adverse impacts, employers must demonstrate that these tests are job-related and consistent with business necessity.

This involves validating the assessment tools through methods outlined by the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (UGESP), which include test validation to show that the tools predict job performance without causing adverse impact​ (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission)​.

Furthermore, measuring adverse impact can be done by using the Four-Fifths Rule. This rule suggests that if the hiring rate for any group is less than 80% of that of the group with the highest rate, it may indicate an adverse impact. Employers need to continuously monitor their hiring practices and outcomes to ensure compliance and fairness​.

To reduce the risk of adverse impact, some companies adopt practices like blind hiring, where personal information that could indicate the candidate’s demographic background is obscured during the resume review phase. This helps minimize unconscious biases in the initial screening process. Additionally, ensuring that job assessments are designed to be inclusive and equitable for all demographic groups can further help mitigate adverse impacts​​.

It’s also advisable for companies to keep detailed records of hiring practices and outcomes to defend against any potential legal challenges regarding discriminatory practices. Regular audits and reviews of hiring processes are essential to ensure they remain fair and effective in selecting the best candidates while complying with legal standards​.

Consulting resources like the EEOC’s guidelines or professional HR advisories can be beneficial for detailed guidance on implementing these practices and information about adverse impacts.

DISC Plus University Logo


Sign up for your Business Discovery Session with one of our DISC assessment specialists.

Fill Out The Form Below to Receive Your DISCovery Session.*

* Discovery session is for business use only. DISC Plus Assessment and diagnostic consultation included.